Bolts ...

Discussion in '1947-1954' started by Haasman, Jun 30, 2012.

  1. Haasman

    Haasman Member

    Joined:
    May 10, 2010
    Messages:
    345
    Location:
    N. CA, south of SF
    So working through the '51 project. Now (!) starting to reassemble. I noticed a couple things: When my son and I took it apart a lot of bolts were loose .... wow .... AND very mis-matched.

    So before going to procure bolts I thougtht I'd check out some questions-

    -For motor mounts, cross-frame pieces etc are grade 8 bolts the only way to go?

    -Bolts for cab mounts, the running board extra arms mounted to the frame, should be be high rated as well?

    -A friend has some stainless bolts that are marked - F593C THE - that I can have for a song and fit, but I am unsure as to whether they would be a good application.

    Thanks for the help as always, stay cool in the hot weather,

    Haasman
     
    Last edited: Jul 1, 2012
  2. Zig

    Zig Member

    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2006
    Messages:
    4,860
    Location:
    Pittsburg KS
    Hang in there, Haasman. I *KNOW* his site has people who can help you with this. They must be pre-4th right now. (?)
    I plan on ordering the stainless set from our host, if they still sell it. So many of the bolts I "undid" ended up breaking. I imagine I might have to remove some stuff somewhere down the line to, say... install a V8... so I might as well use stainless to avoid the bolt breaking thing again...
    BTW, I got my cab mount hardware from our host. Good stuff.
     
  3. Haasman

    Haasman Member

    Joined:
    May 10, 2010
    Messages:
    345
    Location:
    N. CA, south of SF
    Thanks Zig! I wonder whether the site when down? .... seriously I was wondering....

    I really want to do a good job and not look back wondering whether this bolt or that fastener was a good choice. I tore the whole truck down because I began to discover so many cobbled things- loose bolts, frayed wiring looms, sticking throttle linkage.

    I bought the cab fastener kit also. I like it and especailly the labeling of the packets. Makes it easy to plan and get it right.

    I'd love to have a V8 in it but my goal is to have a fairly original truck with some discrete modern improvements- front discs, breaker-less points, three-point seat belts, maybe a hidden radio.

    Just want to cruise on these warm summer nights with my gal riding by my side.

    Haasman
     
  4. 1 Hotrod

    1 Hotrod Member

    Joined:
    Aug 9, 2011
    Messages:
    52
    Location:
    Wisconsin
    Grade 5 or 8 will work fine, most stainless bolts are a low grade (lower than grade 5) that work good for things like putting your box together, bolting on your fenders and such. Also use an anti seize on the stainless. You can get high strength stainless bolts but they are expensive.
     
  5. Haasman

    Haasman Member

    Joined:
    May 10, 2010
    Messages:
    345
    Location:
    N. CA, south of SF
    My thinking exactly. Do you/anybody know of F593C THE stainless? It's strength rating?

    Haasman
     
  6. Zig

    Zig Member

    Joined:
    Oct 14, 2006
    Messages:
    4,860
    Location:
    Pittsburg KS
    I hear you~

    I don't think there would be much that would top your dream. For me, my gal IS my truck... ;) My wife riding with me would be ... okay! :rolleyes:
     
  7. 1 Hotrod

    1 Hotrod Member

    Joined:
    Aug 9, 2011
    Messages:
    52
    Location:
    Wisconsin
    I did a search on SS bolts and came up with this. Do a goggle on F593C stainless bolts and you'll come up with a lot of info on those bolts.

    .



    There are several misconceptions about stainless steel bolts and other fasteners. This guide is intended to clear up some common misunderstandings, but in a format that that is short and simplified.

    1. Stainless Steel is Stainless Steel.
    Not at all true. Steel is an alloy of Iron and trace amounts of Carbon, with some other elements in the mix, too. Making stainless steel requires the addition of other alloying agents, among them are chromium, manganese, molybdenum, nickel, phosphorous, silicon, and/or sulfur. Depending on the amount of these and other elements, many different grades of stainless steel can be produced and there are several grades suitable for making bolts and other fasteners with. The most common stainless steel is some version of "18-8"--that is, using approximately 18% chromium and 8% nickel. Common grades of stainless steel are 410 (Also called C1), 302, 304 (302 and 304 are also called A2), 305, and 316 (Also called A4). ( a version of 316 with additional molybdenum is labeled "2343") I've listed those grades in bold ordered from lowest corrosion resistance to highest corrosion resistance. Of the boltmakng alloys listed above, 302, 304, 305 are all based on "18-8" stainless. Put another way: If you ask the seller what kind of stainless steel his products are made from, and he says "18-8" or "A2", he hasn't told you much because there are various versions of 18-8, and at least two versions of "A2" stainless steel. F593C is an American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) specification for 304 stainless steel.

    2. Stainless steel bolts are stronger than ordinary steel bolts
    This is clearly not true for the majority of stainless steel bolts. Stainless steel in general has very little carbon, and because of that, most grades of stainless steel cannot be hardened by heat treatment. Stainless steel bolts are, in most cases, just slightly stronger than Grade 2 hardware store junk bolts, and in nearly all cases, significantly less than Grade 5. You do NOT want to use common-grade stainless fasteners in any application that would call for a hardened (Grade 5 or Grade 8, or stronger) fastener. ARP makes a fine line of stainless bolts that have a tensile strength of approximately 170,000 lbs per square inch. This is greater tensile strength than a typical Grade 8 fastener, but keep in mind that tensile strength is not the only measure of bolt quality/strength. Common grades of stainless steel may have reasonable tensile strength, but significantly less yield strength than a "regular" steel bolt--the stainless bolts are more "stretchy". Those ARP-made bolts are the ONLY stainless fasteners I'm aware of that are suitable for general use. There may be others--if you know of any, please let me know!

    3. Stainless steel doesn't corrode
    Stainless steel is more correctly called "corrosion resistant" steel. Some grades are more resistant to corrosion than others, and grades have been developed that are highly resistant to corrosion caused by specific uses: for example, 304 is subject to pitting when used in an environment heavy in chlorides, while 316 is less reactive to chloride.

    4. Stainless Steel is not magnetic
    Stainless in general tends to be LESS magnetic than "ordinary" steel, and some grades are non-magnetic. Stainless steel bolts can become slightly magnetic when processed by cold working. Even though the "raw material" going into the boltmaking machines is non-magnetic, the process of forming the head and threads may cause the bolts coming out of the machine to be somewhat magnetic.

    5. Rolled threads are somehow "special".
    It is absolutely true that rolled threads are better than cut threads in terms of strength and accuracy. But since NOBODY produces common-sized bolts by cutting the threads, it's kind of pointless to brag about rolled threads! In a production environment, it's actually cheaper to roll the threads rather than cut them, and it produces better results because the threads are "forged" and the grain of the metal is pressed into shape, while with cut threads the grain of the metal is disturbed by the cutting process. Huge diameter fasteners of low production volume, or "ready rod", long lengths of threaded rod, may--or may not--have cut threads. Still, ordinary-sized bolts will have rolled threads.

    I received a communication of interest from eBay member alleygnat. In it, he told me:
    "I would add one additional item to your discussion regarding rolled threads: Though it it correct that rolled threads are stronger due to the residual work left in them, residual stress can be relieved at prolonged exposure to elevated temperatures thus eliminating any benefit. However, more important to the topic is that threads with residual work (Rolled Threads) are far less corrosion resistant than cut threads. I've seen many a boat with rust running down the hull from bolts with oxidized threads with still bright heads."
    I have not verified his claim that rolled threads are susceptible to corrosion more than cut threads.

    Another issue with common grades of stainless steel is that the threads often seize ("gall") between the bolt and the nut. I suggest the use of an anti-seize compound, coupled to CAREFUL USE OF THE TORQUE WRENCH when tightening stainless steel. You MUST use a torque setting on the wrench suitable for the mechanical limits of the fastener, as adjusted for the reduced thread friction inherent when using a thread lubricant like anti-sieze compounds. As a rule of thumb, and unless the manufacturer says otherwise: Consider a stainless steel fastener to be capable of Grade 2 torque loads, and then adjust the torque DOWNWARD by 20% because of the lubricant properties of the anti-sieze.

    Example: A common 304 (A2) 3/8-16 stainless bolt should accept the same torque as a 3/8-16 Grade 2 bolt--only about 20 ft/lbs. But since you've lubricated the threads with anti-seize compound, you'd reduce the torque by 20%, for a torque-wrench-setting of 16 ft/lbs. That is NOT VERY MUCH for a 3/8 bolt!!! There are stronger stainless bolts--some but not all 316 alloy bolts will take almost but not quite Grade 5 torque specs, but again you must adjust downward when you use anti-sieze. If you're used to working with hardened fasteners (Grade 5 and Grade 8) you won't believe how little torque is the maximum acceptable amount.

    Generally, a manufacturer will put a trade mark of some sort on the bolt head. For example, many stainless steel bolts have the initials "THE" in raised letters on the bolt head. The THE signifies the bolt was made by Tong Hwei Enterprises, somewhere in the Far East--most likely Taiwan, although THE has factories in China and Malaysia as well.

    You might want to check out my "other" Grade 8 vs. 8.2 bolt guide

    If this guide has been helpful, please give me a "Yes" vote by clicking the button below. If you have suggestions for improvement, you can contact me through the "My Messages" feature of eBay by clicking on my user name above, and then click on "Contact Member". Thanks, all.

    Entire contents copyright (C) 2007, 2008 Camino3X2 Feel free to LINK to this Guide in your auctions.

    Guide ID: 10000000001623345Guide created: 08/15/06 (updated 06/29/12)
     
    Last edited: Jul 2, 2012
  8. vwnate1

    vwnate1 Member

    Joined:
    Jan 1, 2000
    Messages:
    11,673
    Location:
    AMERICA !
    Hardware

    Now you see why I didn't respond .

    I'm always just picking up old original hardware and stashing it as sooner or later you'll need it , I just de rust it and grease the threads before assembling .

    Time consuming but factory hardware rarely ever fails , even when it's 60 years old .
     
  9. Haasman

    Haasman Member

    Joined:
    May 10, 2010
    Messages:
    345
    Location:
    N. CA, south of SF
    Thanks for all that info! It is a great overview of fasteners.

    Nate- I saved each part/section in a ziplock bag. When assembling I am seeing a wide variety of fasteners from the previous owners at a given place on the truck. I thought it smart to try and standardize with the same type/style/quality if I am going to replace the mismatched ones.

    This is very educational. I didn't know stainless is was slightly less magnetic, takes less torque or that a harder rated bolt (grade 5 or 8) take less torque. Amazing. My auto-epereince is german where the quality of the fasteners and their even and proper torque is everything.

    Good thread. (sorry about the pun)

    Thanks for everyone's help.

    Haasman
     
    Last edited: Jul 3, 2012
  10. coilover

    coilover Member

    Joined:
    Mar 30, 2005
    Messages:
    2,564
    Location:
    Plano US
    I never use stainless except for high corrosion areas, high heat areas, or "look purty" areas. I never use grade 8 other than head/main bolts, high wear areas like clutch and brake pivots, or if it has a nut on it. If you have ever had to remove a broken grade 8 bolt that has been screwed into a blind hole like a manifold, water pump, bell housing, etc., then you know what I mean. Bolt cabinet is stocked with grade 5 which is fine for 90% of what one needs, is quite strong, and can be drilled.
     
  11. Haasman

    Haasman Member

    Joined:
    May 10, 2010
    Messages:
    345
    Location:
    N. CA, south of SF
    Interesting Evan. Thanks for your posting. I haven't drilled such fasteners but I am hearing the nightmare.

    Over sixty years ago this truck was assembled. After being torn apart down to the frame, I am now putting it back together again. All the parts and pieces for me talk of the truck's history. Kind of a forensic in a way- Why for instance, did it only have two of the four trans mount bolts tight? Why did it have dual-carbs and manifold but its throttle would always stick when wide open? Or why was the cab almost rust free but the drain holes were full of dirt and sediment?

    While working on the truck tonight I found the PO had used 8's on the transmission cross member. Does this part need grade 8 fasteners?

    Haasman
     
    Last edited: Jul 3, 2012
  12. coilover

    coilover Member

    Joined:
    Mar 30, 2005
    Messages:
    2,564
    Location:
    Plano US
    Grade 8 for crossmember bolts are fine but not necessary. As long as you can get to the nut on any grade bolt it's easy to cut the head or nut off in case all else fails. Just don't use them where you can't get to the back side and would have to drill out.
     

Share This Page