I don't think that the type of oil is the issue here. I think the underlying issue is simply this: put whatever oil you like ( mine starts with a "P" and ends with a "Zoil"). I've used that oil forever, HD30 in the summer and 20W in the winter on all of the old 216's i've had. My point is: it doesn't matter what you use as long as you check your oil level, change it regularly and maintain proper tune up on these old 'bolts. Nothing beats an old stovebolt as far as reliability as long as you keep them maintained! My dad bought my '50 in '83 and run it every day hauling trash, gravel, hay, etc until '98 with nothing but regular oil changes and occassional points, plugs and condensers. In the immortal words of Forrest Gump: "That's all i have to say about that!"